In a departure from the two previous books in the Timeless series, For a Lifetime is told from two points of view: identical twins Grace and Hope. Both are time-crossers, with their consciousnesses living in two separate times: 1692 and 1912. They are both twenty-four years old, and the time is coming when they each must decide when to live the rest of their lives.

In 1692, they are the daughters of widowed Puritan Uriah Eaton.

They work in their father’s business, the Salem village ordinary (ordinary is a new-to-me term which apparently refers to the local tavern and eating establishment). Anyone who knows anything about American history will know this is a challenging time and place—the Salem witch trials are about to begin, with Grace and Hope stuck right in the middle.

In 1912, Grace is a journalist and Hope is an aviatrix.

It’s therefore no surprise that both women have already decided they will stay in 1912, where their time-crossing mother still lives, and where women are viewed as people with rights, not possessions under the control of their fathers and husbands.

The story starts in 1692, and is told from Grace’s point of view. Based on the previous stories, I was expecting the whole story to be from Grace’s point of view so was a little discombobulated when I realised the 1912 portions were being told from Hope’s point of view. The two women have very different characters and very different voices, so it was easy enough to tell the difference once I realised they were each telling a portion of the story (the identity of the point of view characters was clearly identified at the beginning of each chapter. However, I have developed a habit of not reading chapter titles, which is why I missed that vital information).

I did find the beginning of the story a little frustrating, particularly as I related to Grace’s character best. I found Hope to be more impetuous and insensitive, almost to the point of being selfish (although that view did change in the second half of the story).

I wondered for a time if I was going to enjoy For a Lifetime as much as I enjoyed the previous books, When the Day Comes and In This Moment. My worries were unfounded: although For a Lifetime took longer to get going than the earlier books, it got better and better as the story progressed, and the ending was both unexpected and excellent.

The book has a romance element, although this isn’t as strong as in the previous stories.

In This Moment forced Maggie to choose between three different men in three timelines, while Grace and Hope had a different choice: each other. While they each do have a romance, the story was more about the relationship between the sisters than their relationships with the men in their lives.

The two historic periods were also interesting to read about. I’m relatively familiar with the history of aviation, but less familiar with the history of the Salem witch trials. On that basis, I enjoyed the 1912 side of the story most, but learned more from the 1692 side. I certainly would not have wanted to live in Puritan America, which came across as religious yet godless … perhaps much like the modern world.

For a Lifetime will be a must-read for anyone who has read the earlier books in the series.

However, it is a standalone story so you don’t have to read the other two in order to enjoy this. (But if you read For a Lifetime, you will absolutely want to go back and read In This Moment, which is the story of Grace and Hope’s mother, and that will ensure you want to read the first book, which is the story of their grandmother).

The best part is finding out the Timeless series is going to continue!

I had thought it was going to be a trilogy, so was a little disappointed to realise this would be the final story. But the end of the book has an excerpt from Across the Ages, which will release in November 2024! I’m looking forward to it already. I hear there will also be a book #5 in 2025.

Thanks to Bethany House and NetGalley for providing a free ebook for review.

About Gabrielle Meyer

Gabrielle lives on the banks of the Upper Mississippi River with her husband and four children. As an employee of the Minnesota Historical Society, she fell in love with the rich history of her state and enjoys writing historical and contemporary novels inspired by real people, places, and events. The river is a constant source of inspiration for Gabrielle, and if you look closely, you will find a river in each of her stories.

When Gabrielle is not writing, you might find her homeschooling her children, cheering them on at sporting and theatrical events, or hosting a gathering at her home with family and friends.

Find Gabrielle Meyer online at:

Website | Facebook | Instagram | Twitter

About For a Lifetime

Grace and Hope are identical twin sisters born with the ability to time-cross together between 1692 Salem, Massachusetts, and 1912 New York City. As their twenty-fifth birthday approaches, they will have to choose one life to keep and one to leave behind forever–no matter the cost.

In 1692, they live and work in their father’s tavern, where they must watch helplessly as the witch trials unfold in their village, threatening everyone. With the help of a handsome childhood friend, they search for the truth behind their mother’s mysterious death, risking everything to expose a secret that could save their lives–or be their undoing.

In 1912, Hope dreams of becoming one of the first female pilots in America, and Grace works as an investigative journalist, uncovering corruption and injustice. After their parents’ orphanage is threatened by an adversary, they enter a contest to complete a perilous cross-country flight under the guidance of a daring French aviator.

The sisters have already decided which timeline they will choose, but an unthinkable tragedy complicates the future they planned for themselves. As their birthday looms, how will they determine the lives–and loves–that are best for both of them?

Find For a Lifetime online at:

Amazon | BookBub | ChristianBook | Goodreads

Don’t forget to click here to check out my Amazon shop for my top picks in Christian fiction!